By Deirdre Golash

What ends does our legal justice process count on and desire to serve while it punishes wrongdoers? Does the punishment of offenders do extra damage than strong for American society? within the Case opposed to Punishment, Deirdre Golash addresses those and different questions about the worth of punishment in modern society.

Drawing on either empirical facts and philosophical literature, this booklet argues that the damage performed by way of punishing felony offenders is eventually morally unjustified. saying that punishment inflicts either meant and unintentional harms on offenders, Golash means that crime might be decreased via addressing social difficulties correlated with excessive crime premiums, equivalent to source of revenue inequality and native social disorganization. Punishment may possibly lessen crime, yet in so doing, reasons a similar volume of injury to offenders. as a substitute, Golash indicates, we should always handle felony acts via trial, conviction, and repayment to the sufferer, whereas additionally offering the felony with the chance to reconcile with society via morally strong motion instead of punishment.

Show description

Read or Download The Case Against Punishment: Retribution, Crime Prevention, and the Law PDF

Best crime & criminals books

Crime Linkage: Theory, Research, and Practice

The expanding portrayal of forensic investigative ideas within the well known media—CSI, for instance, has led to criminals changing into "forensically conscious" and extra cautious approximately abandoning actual facts at a criminal offense scene. This offers legislations enforcement with an important challenge: how can they realize serial offenders in the event that they can't depend upon actual forensic proof?

The Oscar Slater Murder Story. New Light On a Classic Miscarriage of Justice

Oscar Slater, a disreptuable German immigrant, dwelling at the edge of the Glaswegian underworld and rancid the proceeds of playing and prostitution, used to be sentenced to loss of life in 1909 for the brutal homicide of Marion Gilchrist, a wealthy spinster who lived with a mystery hoard of valuable jewels hidden in her dresser in Edwardian Glasgow's trendy West Princes highway.

The Cartel: The Inside Story of Britain's Biggest Drugs Gang

A world group. Billions in revenues. yet, in contrast to Tesco or BP, few have heard of it. The Cartel is Britain’s greatest medicines association, a shadowy community stretching from the freezing, foggy banks of the Mersey to the glittering marinas of Marbella, from the espresso retailers of Amsterdam to the buying and selling flooring of Canary Wharf.

The forger's spell : a true story of Vermeer, Nazis, and the greatest art hoax of the twentieth century

As riveting as an international battle II mystery, The Forger's Spell is the real tale of Johannes Vermeer and the small-time Dutch painter, Han van Meegeren, who dared to impersonate Vermeer centuries later. The con man's mark used to be Hermann Goering, the most reviled leaders of Nazi Germany and a enthusiast collector of artwork.

Additional resources for The Case Against Punishment: Retribution, Crime Prevention, and the Law

Example text

To put the point another way, many of the crimes that offenders would otherwise commit may simply be relocated to the interior of the prison, where they are extremely unlikely to find their way into official statistics. 26 Thus, even given the significant crime reduction effect documented by Levitt, it is improbable that the higher incarceration rate that would have prevented these crimes could have been justified on utilitarian grounds. Levitt’s study looks at the marginal prisoner—the type of prisoner who is released to relieve overcrowding—rather than the average one.

Moreover, it is not unlikely that such failures of rational calculation are more common among those likely to More Good than Harm? | 25 commit crimes. Individuals who have cognitive problems such as mental illness or retardation, or emotional difficulties such as poor impulse control, or who simply have learned through unfortunate experience that the future is unpredictable, are certainly overrepresented in the prison population. Most people have other reasons—such as reasons of conscience and effects on reputation—to refrain from committing serious crimes.

On this view, income inequality is not an accident, but a necessity: [T]he basic logic of this cultural ethos actually presupposes high levels of inequality. A competitive allocation of monetary rewards requires both winners and losers, and winning and losing have meaning only when rewards are distributed unequally. 47 On the short end of economic inequality, young men who see no prospect of material success through legitimate means seek that prize through illegitimate ones, of which the drug market is the prime example.

Download PDF sample

Rated 4.03 of 5 – based on 40 votes